So instead I decided to try again using mostly black and orange in the center and not using as many different fabrics. Then I added the piano key border in the purples and greens.
It’s still a bit crazy, but I like it better than the first version. I put it on my kitchen table, and it fits perfectly there. I think I need a table topper there alll year round!
I ended up just adding a purple border to the original table topper to help tone it down a bit and put that one on my other table.